 Horrendous Disc makes #4 on the list... |
wakachiwaka 
Ceremonial Kernel
Registration Date: 07-26-2007
Posts: 1,209
Location: Glendale, CA
Thread Starter 
 |
|
Well, the blog is called "The Greatest Christian Albums Of All Time", rather than "The Best...". Not to split hairs here, but I think semantically the word "greatest" implies a bit more in terms of cultural impact and establishment of purpose than does the word "best".
By comparison, look at any similar list of mainstream rock records - the aforementioned "Sgt. Pepper's" usually ranks near the top, and why? Because it was a revolutionary game-changer in a way "Abbey Road" (or even "Revolver") never was - it was the album that broke all the rules about what popular music and recording could be, and signalled a major sea change for the group itself. Yes, in retrospect the Beatles made better artistic statements before and since, but "Sgt. Pepper" stands as the most prominent defining moment both for the Beatles themselves, and for the greater culture. To argue that a different record (or artist) should have made the cut on purely artistic merits sort of misses part of the whole point.
And Ritchie, I highly recommend any of D&K's early work, up to and including their live double-disc "No Turning Back" - IMHO, those albums stand with the best CCM had to offer at the time (including what DA was doing back then).
|
|
03-12-2010 11:33 |
|
|
Ritchie_az
Ceremonial Kernel
Registration Date: 07-02-2008
Posts: 2,139
Location: Arizona
|
|
"And Ritchie, I highly recommend any of D&K's early work, up to and including their live double-disc "No Turning Back" - IMHO, those albums stand with the best CCM had to offer at the time"
I have owned (and probably still do own) several D&K albums. They, along with Petra, Whiteheart, Whitecross, etc, etc, etc, were staples when I was a kid. I'm just not a big fan of any of D&K's albums... early ones or late ones. Did they record some good songs? Sure. But how many really bad ones does one have to dig through to find them?
__________________
So I can type anything I want here? No?
My Photography Blog
|
|
|
03-12-2010 12:30 |
|
|
dennis
Ubique Epoque
Registration Date: 09-19-2002
Posts: 13,303
Location: In not-quite earth, in not-quite heaven.
|
|
Maybe 20 years ago Sgt Pepper ranked in the top 2 of albums lists, but now in recent years there seems to be a trend of ranking Revolver or Abbey Road higher.
In terms of sales, according to my 100 topselling albums of the 60s, the top seller is The White Album. Go figure.
__________________
I'm talkin' bout the Vinyl , the Holy Vinyl.
|
|
|
03-12-2010 17:08 |
|
|
dennis
Ubique Epoque
Registration Date: 09-19-2002
Posts: 13,303
Location: In not-quite earth, in not-quite heaven.
|
|
Otherwise "Greatest" or "Best" however you want to slice it, it is all opinion.
Does not matter if you are gauging quality or cultural impact, it's just opinion.
Still, makes for great discussion.
__________________
I'm talkin' bout the Vinyl , the Holy Vinyl.
|
|
|
03-12-2010 17:11 |
|
|
pegotico
Luteous Llama
Registration Date: 10-23-2009
Posts: 284
|
|
| quote: |
Originally posted by wakachiwaka
Well, the blog is called "The Greatest Christian Albums Of All Time", rather than "The Best...". Not to split hairs here, but I think semantically the word "greatest" implies a bit more in terms of cultural impact and establishment of purpose than does the word "best".
). |
yep, i agree but sometimes greatest can also be the best, so that will depend on the person doing the list
__________________
"Everything in Christ astonishes me. His spirit overawes me, and His will confounds me ... I search in vain in history to find the similar to Jesus Christ, or anything that can approach the gospel." Napoleon Bonaparte
|
|
|
03-12-2010 17:12 |
|
|
pegotico
Luteous Llama
Registration Date: 10-23-2009
Posts: 284
|
|
| quote: |
Originally posted by dennis
Maybe 20 years ago Sgt Pepper ranked in the top 2 of albums lists, but now in recent years there seems to be a trend of ranking Revolver or Abbey Road higher.
In terms of sales, according to my 100 topselling albums of the 60s, the top seller is The White Album. Go figure. |
no wonder 
, they are the best
__________________
"Everything in Christ astonishes me. His spirit overawes me, and His will confounds me ... I search in vain in history to find the similar to Jesus Christ, or anything that can approach the gospel." Napoleon Bonaparte
|
|
|
03-12-2010 17:13 |
|
|
dennis
Ubique Epoque
Registration Date: 09-19-2002
Posts: 13,303
Location: In not-quite earth, in not-quite heaven.
|
|
They are! 
And they sold a ton of records.
quality and record sales does happen from time to time.
__________________
I'm talkin' bout the Vinyl , the Holy Vinyl.
|
|
|
03-12-2010 17:15 |
|
|
Audiori J
Administrator
Registration Date: 11-27-2004
Posts: 7,728
Location: "Clowns to the left of me! Jokers to the right! Here I AM stuck in the middle with you." - Stealers Wheel
|
|
I think a lot of times its a difference between personal opinion and public opinion. They are two different things. I can hold the opinion that DA is the greatest band ever, but I know that would only be my own personal taste and not be the same thing as mass public opinion which lists bands like the Beatles or Rolling Stones as the greatest. Personal opinion could be based on just what I like vs what I don't, but mass public opinion is based on things like popularity and cultural influence.
From this perspective, I could have a personal top ten albums that to me are ones that will always be in my play list. But if someone asked me what the top ten albums of all time for the world is, I know the list would be very different.
__________________
"Education is the ability to listen to almost anything without losing your temper or your self-confidence." ~ Robert Frost
|
|
|
03-12-2010 22:58 |
|
|
pegotico
Luteous Llama
Registration Date: 10-23-2009
Posts: 284
|
|
| quote: |
Originally posted by Audiori J
I think a lot of times its a difference between personal opinion and public opinion. They are two different things. I can hold the opinion that DA is the greatest band ever, but I know that would only be my own personal taste and not be the same thing as mass public opinion which lists bands like the Beatles or Rolling Stones as the greatest. Personal opinion could be based on just what I like vs what I don't, but mass public opinion is based on things like popularity and cultural influence.
From this perspective, I could have a personal top ten albums that to me are ones that will always be in my play list. But if someone asked me what the top ten albums of all time for the world is, I know the list would be very different. |
yep, the thing with public opinion is that the majority will vote for "the most famous". It will always go to the most popular! Lets take this list for example from RS magazine
http://www.rollingstone.com/news/story/5...ums_of_all_time
London calling from the Clash at # 8 and
Dark Side of the Moon from PF at #43
Pink floyd is not a popular band but their first spot on the list is 43. Pink Floyd's album is superior (no doubt about it). Pink Floyd is superior to the clash in every aspect!!!!This list doesnt have my respect, it just tells me that the ppl involve need some serious help lol.
Also I believe that the christian market shouldnt be combine with the secular market when it comes to greatest bands list, etc It just makes things more more more difficult than what they are. 
I cant compare the Beatles and DA. The beatles are the beatles, and DA is my favorite christian band.
__________________
"Everything in Christ astonishes me. His spirit overawes me, and His will confounds me ... I search in vain in history to find the similar to Jesus Christ, or anything that can approach the gospel." Napoleon Bonaparte
|
|
|
03-13-2010 10:40 |
|
|
dennis
Ubique Epoque
Registration Date: 09-19-2002
Posts: 13,303
Location: In not-quite earth, in not-quite heaven.
|
|
Pink Floyd not popular??
Dark Side of the Moon was on the Billboard Top 100 for 15 years!!
__________________
I'm talkin' bout the Vinyl , the Holy Vinyl.
|
|
|
03-13-2010 20:33 |
|
|
wakachiwaka
Ceremonial Kernel
Registration Date: 07-26-2007
Posts: 1,209
Location: Glendale, CA
Thread Starter
|
|
Right - I'd just about wager that in every measurable sense, Pink Floyd has always been demonstrably more popular than the Clash...
|
|
|
03-13-2010 22:52 |
|
|
Tyler Durden
Luteous Llama
Registration Date: 04-11-2002
Posts: 261
Location: Our generation has had no Great Depression, no Great War. Our war is a spiritual war.
|
|
At least Horrendous Disk is ahead of Keith Green. I do like eight of the top ten. It reminds me that I was very lucky to be growing up in the best time for Christian music. What ever happened to originality? What about music that isn't overwrought with fake emotion and cliched lyrics.
Over 30 years as a fan of DA. Wow.
|
|
|
03-13-2010 22:59 |
|
|
pegotico
Luteous Llama
Registration Date: 10-23-2009
Posts: 284
|
|
| quote: |
Originally posted by wakachiwaka
Right - I'd just about wager that in every measurable sense, Pink Floyd has always been demonstrably more popular than the Clash... |
If you read carefully my commentary I never compare pink floyd with the clash in popularity, I said PF is not a popular band and then I said that how could it be possible that one of the best "dark side of the moon" be at 43 while the clash album at 8. And now I add that DSOTM is better than many that made the top 20.
My first language is spanish so go easy on my ideas, sometimes I want to say so many things and I make a mess
pink floyd in terms of popularity compare with a lot of bands and artist is less popular and that is because the music they make is psychedelic. Their album Division Bell received very poor reviews and "marooned" is a masterpiece of a song and if you come to think about it Pink floyd winning a grammy for an instrumental song surprises me
__________________
"Everything in Christ astonishes me. His spirit overawes me, and His will confounds me ... I search in vain in history to find the similar to Jesus Christ, or anything that can approach the gospel." Napoleon Bonaparte
|
|
|
03-13-2010 23:24 |
|
|
Ritchie_az
Ceremonial Kernel
Registration Date: 07-02-2008
Posts: 2,139
Location: Arizona
|
|
| quote: |
| What ever happened to originality? What about music that isn't overwrought with fake emotion and cliched lyrics. |
Good questions.
__________________
So I can type anything I want here? No?
My Photography Blog
|
|
|
03-14-2010 00:08 |
|
|
dennis
Ubique Epoque
Registration Date: 09-19-2002
Posts: 13,303
Location: In not-quite earth, in not-quite heaven.
|
|
Pink Floyd has sold over 200 Million albums worldwide.
Dark Side of the Moon spent 15 years in the Billboard 100.
Pink Floyd is one of the most popular bands ever, bad album reviews or not.
__________________
I'm talkin' bout the Vinyl , the Holy Vinyl.
|
|
|
03-14-2010 05:09 |
|
|
dennis
Ubique Epoque
Registration Date: 09-19-2002
Posts: 13,303
Location: In not-quite earth, in not-quite heaven.
|
|
I am talking about album sales.
Worldwide they have sold 200 million records.
That makes as popular as the other bands you mentioned.
__________________
I'm talkin' bout the Vinyl , the Holy Vinyl.
|
|
|
03-14-2010 10:08 |
|
|
dennis
Ubique Epoque
Registration Date: 09-19-2002
Posts: 13,303
Location: In not-quite earth, in not-quite heaven.
|
|
| quote: |
Originally posted by dennis
I am talking about album sales.
Worldwide they have sold 200 million records.
That makes as popular as the other bands you mentioned. |
Just so were clear, I'm not taklking about what critics think or what your buddies think I am talking sales figures. Any band that can sell 200 Million records is very, very, huge, mega, superstar popular.
Plus you need to remember that Pink Floyd was not a "singles" band, they were an "Album" band.
__________________
I'm talkin' bout the Vinyl , the Holy Vinyl.
This post has been edited 1 time(s), it was last edited by dennis: 03-14-2010 10:27.
|
|
|
03-14-2010 10:26 |
|
|
Ritchie_az
Ceremonial Kernel
Registration Date: 07-02-2008
Posts: 2,139
Location: Arizona
|
|
"My first language is spanish"
Pegotico, just wondering where you're from. For some reason "Pegotico" sounds South American to me (Columbian maybe?).
__________________
So I can type anything I want here? No?
My Photography Blog
|
|
|
03-14-2010 11:28 |
|
|
pegotico
Luteous Llama
Registration Date: 10-23-2009
Posts: 284
|
|
| quote: |
Originally posted by Ritchie_az
"My first language is spanish"
Pegotico, just wondering where you're from. For some reason "Pegotico" sounds South American to me (Columbian maybe?). |
pegote is like a chunk of something so pegotico is a little chunk of something, thats how I call my little girl. I from DR which is in the caribbean next to puerto rico, we have the best baseball players in the major leagues
__________________
"Everything in Christ astonishes me. His spirit overawes me, and His will confounds me ... I search in vain in history to find the similar to Jesus Christ, or anything that can approach the gospel." Napoleon Bonaparte
|
|
|
03-14-2010 13:17 |
|
|
|
huh???